It is often assumed that the costs of a challenge to a will are paid from the estate This is not always the case as this recent judgement of Justice Nuala Butler shows in the case of O’Connell v. O’Connell and Anor. [2023] IEHC 215 where she set out the principles applicable to this discretionary relief.

On the issue of costs, the court held that the nephew was not entitled to his costs from the estate for several reasons, including inter alia that the nephew ran the case in the knowledge that the legal fees would have a negative effect on the amount of the estate and the other party had made a reasonable “without prejudice” offer.

View more details in our article for Who pays the legal costs in a challenge to a will?